Introduction

Are you familiar with this? You click on a link and instead of the expected page, a “404 — page not found” message appears. Annoying, isn't it? Every Internet user has already experienced 404 errors like this. In this guide, you'll find out what the mysterious 404 error is all about and why it's important for website operators and SEOs. We start with the basics for beginners and then dive into advanced tips. You'll learn Exactly what a 404 error is, when it becomes a problem, what effects it has on SEO, how to fix typical 404 causes And like you your website through monitoring and best practices Make 404 fit.

What is a 404 error?

A 404 error Is the HTTP status code for “Not found”. In simple terms, this means that the server could not find the requested page at the requested URL. Imagine you send a letter to an address that doesn't exist — the letter comes with the stamp “Recipient unknown” back to you. In the same way, the server uses status code 404 to report that no page exists at the desired web address.

For you as a user, a 404 error usually means that you either clicked on an incorrect link or mistyped, or that the page was moved or deleted. For website operators, 404 errors are generally not uncommon — every website has a few of them over time. But it is important to understand When a 404 error is harmless and when action is needed.

‍

404 error: When problematic, when harmless?

Not every 404 error is the end of the world. On the contrary: 404 belongs to the web just as an address belongs to a letter. Harmless For example, is a 404 error when someone calls up a fantasy URL that never existed. In such a case, the error is even intentional — the page simply does not exist and should not exist. Search engines like Google even expect your site to return a 404 code for URLs that don't exist.

Problematic On the other hand, it will be when actually existing or important pages mistakenly end as 404. If this happens to many users, it causes frustration: The visitor searches for something on your site and ends up in a dead end. This looks unprofessional and can cause users to drop out. It is also critical from a search engine perspective when numerous important URLs suddenly lead nowhere. On the one hand, the Google bot wastes crawl budget (it repeatedly tries to load the pages that don't exist), on the other hand, valuable content can disappear from the index if it is reported permanently as 404.

So the rule of thumb is: Isolated 404 errors are normal and no reason to panic. However, when many users or important content If you are affected, you must intervene. Large amounts of 404 errors can occur, especially when making major changes to the website (such as a relaunch) — particular care should be taken here.

Effects of 404 errors on SEO

404 errors can have various effects on your site's search engine optimisation. Here are the most important points you should know:

Crawling & Crawl Budget

Search engine crawlers like Googlebot regularly crawl your site. If they encounter many 404 errors, your Crawl budget strain. In simple terms, the crawl budget is the number of pages that Google crawls on your site in a specific period of time. Every unnecessary 404 page that is crawled is a missed opportunity for the bot to visit a working (potentially important) page instead. A few 404s here and there are okay, but when hundreds or thousands of orphaned URLs exist, the crawler wastes time. In the worst case scenario, important pages are crawled less often because the bot is busy with dead links.

Indexing and rankings

Pages that return a 404 status code are no longer listed in Google's index. That means any page on your site that is a 404 can't be found in search results. This is intentional if the page should actually be gone. It is problematic when actually relevant content accidentally ends up on a 404 page — it then loses its ranking because Google removes it from the index. In addition, goes incoming “link juice” (i.e. inherited link strength of backlinks) lost if a linked page only outputs a 404. The linking page points into the void, and the SEO value of the backlink fizzles out. In short: Many or important 404 errors can indirectly affect your rankings because they pull content and linked power out of traffic.

User Experience

Last but not least, she suffers user experience if there are too many 404 errors. Imagine you're a visitor to a website and you click on an interesting product link — but instead of information, you get “Page not found.” You're probably annoyed and may leave the website completely. For operators, this means lost potential customers or readers. A high bounce rate due to frustrated users can also indirectly affect SEO signals (e.g. when users quickly click back to Google search). This is why: Mitigate 404 errors in such a way that the user is ideally offered an alternative solution instead of simply ending up in nowhere.

Typical causes of 404 errors

Why do 404 errors occur anyway? Here are some of the most common causes:

• Rename or move content without redirection: If you change a page's title or URL (e.g. rename a category in the shop) and don't set up a redirect, the old URL will go blank. The same applies when moving articles to a new directory — without a redirect, old links fall by the wayside.
• Delete pages or products: In content management and shop systems, content is often deleted when it is out of date or a product is no longer available. By default, this usually produces a 404 error. When a popular product is removed from the range, many users or external links can still point to the old product page — and then encounter an error.
• Website relaunch or domain change: A relaunch is predestined for 404 chaos, especially if the URL structure changes. Example: You're switching from one shop system to another and your URLs suddenly look different. Without a redirection concept, all old links will no longer work. Google doesn't know the new URLs yet, but is trying to crawl the old ones — the result: tons of 404 errors. Thorough redirect planning is therefore essential for relaunches.
• Dynamic URLs and technical errors: Some websites (or plugins) automatically generate URLs, for example for filters, searches, or session IDs. If something goes wrong here — for example a bug in a plugin — countless incorrect URLs can result that lead nowhere. Such technical problems can produce a lot of 404 errors in a short period of time (sometimes even millions if a loop occurs, for example).
• Seasonal or temporary pages: Many marketing teams create temporary pages (e.g. landing pages for Easter, Christmas, sales campaigns). After the action is over, these pages are often removed and not redirected. This creates a new round of 404 errors with every action if the old links are still circulating somewhere.
• External links and typos: You are not responsible for all broken links yourself. Perhaps another website has linked to your page incorrectly (e.g. a typo in the URL), or there are still external links to old content that you have removed. Even users who manually enter URLs sometimes mistyped. These external factors also lead to 404 errors on your site, even though everything is “correctly” linked internally.
• Malicious attacks or spam: In rare cases, spam bots also intentionally generate many calls to invalid URLs, e.g. to interfere with crawling. Fortunately, such “attacks” are rare and Google usually recognises them and ignores them — yet an unusually large number of 404 errors can occur in your logs or the Search Console in the short term.

404 error solutions

Thankfully, you don't just have to accept 404 issues. There are various Solutions and strategiesto fix 404 errors or mitigate their effects:

• Set up 301 redirects: The best solution for permanently removed or moved content is permanent redirection (301 redirect). This will redirect users and search engines from the old, no longer available URL to another, suitable page. In this way, neither the user nor Google fizzle out, but end up with a useful alternative. In the online shop example, you could redirect sold-out products to the appropriate category (e.g. all “Winter Boots XL” to the general “Winter Boots” overview page). A 301 redirect works like a forwarding order at the post office: It tells the browser and Google that the requested address has been permanently moved. As a result, the “SEO value” (link strength of the old URL) is largely retained.
• 302 (temporary) redirects only in exceptional cases: One 302 redirection Says that the redirection only temporarily is. It should be used sparingly — for example when a site is offline for a short time or comes back soon. For permanent changes, 302 is wrong; always use 301 here, otherwise Google thinks the old page could return and may keep it in the index longer.
• HTTP 410 Gone — Removed permanently: If you've permanently deleted a page and it's really Not a substitute at all Is there, can you also use the status instead of 404 410 Gone send. 410 signals to search engines “this page is gone and won't come back.” The effect: Google will normally re-crawl this URL less often after a 410 than with a 404 (where the bot may look even longer to see if the page reappears). 410 can be useful to make it clear to Google that it is not worth wasting any more time on this URL. But beware: For users, 410 is just as much a “not found” experience as 404 — the difference is primarily on a technical level.
• Provide an easy-to-use 404 page: No matter how hard you try, there will always be a few 404 errors. That is why it is important to have a good 404 page to have. Make your error page helpful and maybe even charming: offer the user links back to the homepage or to popular categories, a search function, or a message such as “The page they were looking for no longer exists, but here are some of our top offers.” This is how you turn a negative experience into an opportunity to keep the visitor on your site after all. Important: The error page itself must of course provide the HTTP status 404. It's no use if your 404 page is delivered as “OK” (200) — then Google won't notice that there is actually an error.
• Use referrals with a sense of proportion: In principle, you should only forward where it makes sense. If you really don't have a suitable replacement for a page you haven't found, it's better to leave the 404 as it is than to redirect the user to a completely irrelevant page. A common mistake is, for example, sending all 404s to the start page in a lump sum. This confuses users and Google often rates something like this as “Soft 404” (i.e. an error message that actually has not been solved at all). If anything, it is better to redirect to thematically related content — or even a well-designed 404 page that helps the user.
• Quick removal from the index (emergency tip): If you need to remove a page from Google search results immediately for urgent reasons (e.g. for legal reasons), you can go to the Google Search Console the tool “Remove URL” use. This allows you to hide a URL from the index for a short time. However, this is only a temporary solution — you should still correctly set the page to 404 or 410 or set up a redirect so that the problem is permanently resolved.

Monitoring and detecting 404 errors

To get to grips with 404 errors, you first need to recognise them. Here are a few ways you can find broken links and error messages:

• Google Search Console: Google's Search Console is your first port of call. Under “Coverage” or “Indexing status” Can you find a report about “Not found” pages (404 errors). Here, Google lists all URLs that Googlebot received a 404 when they were called. You can also see when Google last tried to crawl that URL. The Search Console therefore gives you a good overview of which 404s Google finds important. (Note: A maximum of 1000 errors are displayed in the web interface. For larger websites, you can export the data via API, but for most cases, the top error pages are enough.)
• Use analytics data: A very practical approach is to look at your web analytics tool (e.g. Google Analytics, Matomo, etc.). There, you can see whether real users have landed on 404 pages. For example, filter in Google Analytics by page title or page URL that contains “404” or “not found” — this way you'll find all page views where users saw an error page. This list is worth its weight in gold: it shows you which broken links actually generate traffic (i.e. have priority). You may discover that many visitors come via a specific broken link — you should then urgently repair or forward it.
• Use crawling tools: To technically check your own website, we recommend crawling programs such as Screaming Frog, Sitebulb or Xenu. These tools crawl your entire website like a search engine bot and report any broken internal links. This allows you to systematically find all internal links that point to 404 pages. You should correct such internal broken links immediately (update or remove the link), as they are completely under your control and easy to fix.
• Broken link analysis of backlinks: You should look for 404 links not only internally, but also externally. With SEO tools (Ahrefs, Semrush, Majestic, etc.) or the Search Console (“Links” section), you can check whether other websites link to URLs that give you a 404 error. Such backlinks are wasted potential! If you discover valuable external links that go nowhere, set up a 301 redirect from the old URL to a suitable current page if possible. In this way, you save the link juice and the visitor from the other side still ends up with you instead of on the error page.
• Regular monitoring: Make a habit of regularly checking your website for 404 errors. It doesn't have to be a daily effort — but a monthly check of the Search Console and Analytics and a quarterly crawling of the page work wonders. This allows you to catch creeping problems in time before hundreds of broken links accumulate.

Best practices and regular maintenance

Finally, a few more Best Practicesso that you have long-term peace of mind from major 404 problems:

1. Schedule redirects when changes are made: Whenever you change a URL or remove content, remember to redirect. It is best to keep a list or table for major updates (e.g. relaunch), where old and new URLs are compared. This is how you ensure that no old link remains unsupplied.
2. Select relevant redirect goals: Redirect a deleted page to another only if the new page is relevant to the user. For similar content, this is ideal (product A -> product B, old blog post -> similar blog post). If there is nothing suitable, leave the page 404 (or 410) and offer the user alternatives on the error page instead of setting a misleading redirect.
3. Design a user-friendly 404 page: Spend a bit of time on your 404 error page. For example, add a search, link suggestions (top articles, categories), and a friendly error message. A humorous sentence or a creative design doesn't hurt either — so the user is more inclined to continue browsing instead of leaving frustrated.
4. Keep internal links up to date: Just check your internal links after major changes (category deleted, article moved). Nothing is more embarrassing than links on your own website that lead nowhere. With a crawling tool or internal CMS features, you can quickly find and fix broken internal links.
5. Fix broken backlinks: Check the backlink reports from your SEO tool or Search Console occasionally (e.g. once a quarter). If high-quality external websites link to a page that you no longer have, you should fix that first. Set up a redirect or maybe even make the content available again if the link is really important.
6. Keep an eye on your crawl budget: Especially if you have a big website, make sure you don't waste Google's crawl budget with unnecessary 404s. For example, delete pointless endless filter URLs or make sure that such URLs are excluded via robots.txt so that Google doesn't get hung up on them. Fewer “trash URLs” mean more efficient crawling of important content.
7. Don't panic with a few 404s: It is almost impossible all Eliminate 404 errors And you don't have to. Google is pretty clever and ignores occasional 404s of its own accord in the long run. A few errors in the Search Console are therefore completely normal. It is important that you remain in control: If there is a sudden increase or important pages are affected, do something — otherwise you can see minor mistakes calmly.
8. Establish a regular routine: Set a recurring appointment (e.g. once a month) to check out the tools mentioned above. This continuous maintenance ensures that 404 issues never get out of hand. It is easier to fix 5 broken links per month than 500 after one year of ignorance.
9. Plan ahead for relaunches: A final tip: If a website relaunch or a major restructuring is pending, plan prior the URL redirects. Create a redirect mapping list of old URLs to new URLs and test it immediately after the relaunch. This is how you catch most 404 errors before users or Google even see them.

If you follow these best practices, you don't have to worry about 404 errors. They are part of the everyday life of every website, but when properly managed, they do no harm. On the contrary, a well-maintained website with functional links offers a better user experience and sends positive signals to search engines.

Conclusion: 404 errors don't have to scare you. By understanding the causes, the right detection tools, and a few proven countermeasures, you'll keep your website healthy and your visitors happy. So take some time to manage 404 — it's worth it for your SEO and your users alike!

‍